Sunday, February 8, 2015

Teaching Students to Learn (Subjects Matter)


In Subjects Matter, I saw many key points reiterated which I’ve seen stressed in other education literature this semester. The main points which stood out to me are choice, authenticity and audience, and explicit instruction coupled with modeling.

The first is choice, in the first example where students went out into the community for their projects, they were given choices as to who their audience would be, how they would reach them and what they were hoping to gain from their efforts. Additionally in the work prior to going out in the field, students were allowed to choose their own tangent to follow for deeper research after everyone read literature on the same topic. Recently, in my SPED class we revisited Gardner’s theory of multiple intelligences. His theory acknowledges that it’s not about how smart you are but about how you are smart. Keeping this in mind, allowing as much choice as to what students research and how they are allowed to present it opens up the way for the most amount of students to be involved and successful.

This leads to the next point which is authenticity.  In addition to choice, students need to feel that their work is meaningful to feel motivated to give it their best effort. This means we need to provide many learning situations in which students read actual material from our current field and are opening discussions about topics that effect their daily lives both big and small. Even beyond that, in Kelly Gallagher’s book Teaching Adolescent Writers, a student confesses “we are forced to write essays on topics that we care nothing about just to make our teachers look good.” He then goes on to include a conversation he had with one of his students who excelled at football but not in his ELA class to ask why that is. The student explained that in football, you have the big game to look forward to. Gallagher goes on to coin the term “Friday Night Lights.” Students need an audience, as in the McDonald’s example in Subjects Matter, they need a community larger than just their teacher that they are actively participating in. This is true for any school subject, students need to know that the work they are doing right now isn’t just practice, it also matters.
The third main point is explicit teaching. Before we can have our students read authentic material, create varied projects, reach out to the community or discuss our subjects, we must teach them how to do all of this. As the example with the reading paragraphs in chapter two, reading itself is something that must be taught, there are concrete steps that a good reader practices and we need to both model and name these for our students. This reminded me of the metaphor in my MLED class that Dr. Horwitz used of students having “backpacks” of literacy. Our jobs as teachers is not to make students figure out how to read our texts, or how to have an intelligent, safe discussion, our job is to teach them exactly how to do those things. If we explicitly hand our students the tools of how to read and think then we leave them with room and time to do the actual thinking.

4 comments:

  1. I really like your point about authenticity. So many students are turned off from learning because they don't see the point of why they are doing what they are doing. Having a real meaning behind the work goes a long way in showing the students that what they do matters. These ideas about extending projects outside of the classroom where they can make some impact on the community is really interesting to me, because I never had the opportunity to do something like that in high school.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hi Michaela,

    I suffered through that SPED exercise with you, so I am going to pose a nagging question about the use of the Multiple Intelligences in the manner we experienced together and as I have experienced in other education classes. First of all, I am a self-proclaimed card-carrying supporter of the idea of the Multiple Intelligences and recognizing the many varieties of cognitive gifts we sentient beings possess. I just question the exercises I have been given to do specifically in my education classes. I distinctly recall my CEP book stating that as the designer of lesson plans you did not have to include all the multiple intelligences in every lesson, and in fact that you should not do that, but rather use them all across a variety of lessons in an effort to provide access to the greatest variety of students. Yet every time I am presented with an exercise on the use of the multiple intelligences in lesson planning, the instruction is to find a way to use all the intelligences in this lesson – just as we were instructed to do for teaching Romeo & Juliet. This seems wrong on two counts: 1) We are variegated individuals that possess more than one variety of intelligence so we should not be singled out as “the naturalist” or “the logical/mathematical one” and 2) Even if we are “the naturalist”, we shouldn’t be assigned tasks seemingly related to that dimension of our self that really have nothing much to do with learning the actual lesson. Imagine trying to understand the message of R&J by picking up twigs that may have contributed to the scenery(!) I am sure this is not what Howard Gardner had in mind.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hi, Michela,
    I agree that authenticity is important. If students believe that what they are doing holds meaning, then they are likely to be more motivated to do it. I appreciate that you made the connection to Gallagher, also. Taking what they are taught in the classroom and going out in the community to further explore these lessons, demonstrates that there is also meaning and authenticity outside of school.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Hi, Michela,
    I agree that authenticity is important. If students believe that what they are doing holds meaning, then they are likely to be more motivated to do it. I appreciate that you made the connection to Gallagher, also. Taking what they are taught in the classroom and going out in the community to further explore these lessons, demonstrates that there is also meaning and authenticity outside of school.

    ReplyDelete