The first thing about Wilhelm’s article which stood out to
me is how crucial it is as a teacher to know your own philosophy of what a
school is for, and also what theories you identify with as the backbone for why
you create a lesson. For example, if you believe the point of school is to
prepare students to be successful in the community whether it be in college, a
technical career or beyond that just in daily life, you must prepare them for a
variety of outcomes. This means that Wilhelm’s ideas about learning how to
complete a task, and learning how to apply the knowledge students are gaining
is more essential than the content itself. As in the example with Swift’s Modest Proposal, it is of very little
benefit if students are exposed to this classic piece of literature if they do
not know how to spot irony in other texts or understand why and when it is
appropriate to use irony. This leads to his idea that when teaching you should
be answering the questions what, why, when and how. If students can answer all
of these questions then they can apply their learning beyond the immediate
content and this creates life-long learners. The best way for students to learn
how to use this knowledge is by showing them how we use our knowledge. This is
my favorite part of the article and something I can’t wait to train my brain to
be an automatic part of my teaching. The article breaks it down into four basic
steps, I do you watch, I do you help, you do I help, and you do. This system is
a clear example of Vygotsky’s scaffolding and allows for a very easy learning
transfer. I like this approach because it is the tangible example of what we’ve
learned in other teaching courses such as 406. It’s using the mindset of
switching from the teacher at the pulpit to the Socratic Method where the
teacher works alongside the students using inquiry and exploration.
I think that you hit the nail on the head by assessing that the reading shows that "Wilhelm’s ideas about learning how to complete a task, and learning how to apply the knowledge students are gaining is more essential than the content itself." And I definitely think that there are a lot of teachers out there who would vehemently disagree. (There are some things you just have to know!) I think that in today's age of high stakes testing and merit based assessment it is even more crucial to strike an appropriate balance between content and skill building. In this light, it seems like reading is a perfect place to balance.
ReplyDeleteI completely agree with your thinking of Vygotsky's method and the Socratic method being a good approach to teaching. I've always thought there is much more to gain by figuring something out for yourself then just having someone else tell you why something is the way it is. I also agree with your statement of how learning to apply knowledge is more essential than the content itself. I'm curious how you ranked the hypothetical teaching situations at the start of the chapter. I ranked Arlene's, Jude's, and Maria's scenarios highly because I felt the life lessons they took away were more important than remembering the facts from the course.
ReplyDeleteHi Michaela,
ReplyDeleteWell this one got me thinking... I imagined a sort of continuum with the teacher-centered model on the right and the student-centered model on the left. I thought two-sided Vygotsky-inspired learning-centered model would be in the middle because rather than focusing on one-sided transmitting or acquiring, this model expects transformation of both the more expert and more novice learners involved in the collaboration. However, the paper considers this 'community of learners' model as so radically different that it 'supersedes the pendulum entirely' and is not just a balance between the two one-sided models. I guess I will beg to differ there. But is the Socratic method equivalent to this Vygotsky-inspired two-sided model? I guess I will never know if Socrates himself was being transformed as he engaged in dialogue, so I will hope so but admit that I have always found the Socratic voice in Plato's dialogues to be pedantic so I would not naturally have equated these methods. I would have put Socratic method more toward the teacher-centered side, but thanks to you I have to hold this question in my mind a bit longer :]
Hey Michela,
ReplyDeleteI think you captured Wilhelm's main point very nicely. These two chapters really had me thinking about things in a different, which like you said, "I can't wait to train my brain to be an automatic part of my teaching." Most of us are comfortable with what we already know, so in order to be more effective teacher we need to train our brains to adapt better learning strategies. I liked how you used the Modest Proposal example to illustrate that learning should go beyond the just the reading of the text. Students definitely need to know how to apply the techniques of what they learned to a different task. So, I also agree that the attention should be placed on strategies and not so much the content. However, I do believe the content also serves a purpose and should be completely neglected. I think we need to find a balance. Great job! I look forward to reading your future posts.