Sunday, February 22, 2015

Undestanding by Design


The three sections discussing UBD all had similar points and some over-arching themes. The main point from chapter one was the three steps, first identify desired results, then determine acceptable evidence ad lastly plan the learning experience and instruction. The main point of UBD is to work “backwards”. It reminds me of the task analysis skill I learned in my SPED class. Creating a lesson by starting with the final, specific outcome helps SPED, ELL and mainstream students. The ultimate goal should be clear, and general enough that it is a theme or skill which can be carried into many different learning situations.
This was a new concept for me as I’m used to creating objectives which are very specific. For instance, “the student will circle the noun in the sentence”.  Big ideas however are much broader and often less concrete than an objective. Perhaps an essential question for a lesson which used the above-mentioned objective would be “Is it important to understand parts of speech in the English language?” It needs to be something that cannot be answered easily with a “right” answer. I liked this idea and I also like the idea of making students aware of the essential question so through all the specific activities and practice they are performing they are working towards their own understandings and answers.
UBD’s concept of understanding is also new to me. It’s the concept you ultimately want the students to master but cannot be something easily taught and is often a misconception they will clarify or a counter-intuitive concept they will explore. There’s a lot packed in these modules and I love the idea of creating lessons by working backwards. First identify your overall theme (essential question) then how you will assess it and what will you accept as mastery (understanding) then choose the tools that will be most powerful in getting to that understanding. What I really would like to do after reading these articles is practice creating essential questions and understanding statements. I understand the concept but I’m not sure I understand it enough to easily create examples. I’d like more practice with this.

3 comments:

  1. Michela, I agree with you that practice writing essential questions and understand statements would be helpful. After reading about UbD, the concepts all make sense and seem like they'd be very helpful with lesson and unit planning. I think that backward design will come pretty easily when we start planning. However, I think coming up with good essential questions is going to be harder than it seems. After reading some of the examples provided in the text, I was thinking that I could use some practice doing this on my own as well.

    ReplyDelete
  2. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I agree with you Michela (and Gemma) about how coming up with an essential question seems like the hardest part and that working backwards from that point seems like it would happen more easily. After all, it should be a question that takes an entire unit, semester/trimester, or year to "answer." I feel like it would take a trial and error process to figure out an appropriate essential question. I can imagine thinking that I finally created a great question and while I plan backwards, learning that maybe my question was too easy to answer or too hard.

    ReplyDelete